I tend to like your articles. This one leaves me cold. In the past, employment and unemployment have been big players in voters sense of what is happening in their area. Now it is clearly inflation, corruption and terrible trade decisions. These are hard to analyze at the local level, I get this.
I am wondering why you choose to tackle this analysis at all. the differences are small, somewhat meaningless compared to inflation, policies and war, and tarrifs. As you point out MSA's are not perfect political boundaries. Perhaps looking for export/import effects of the tarrifs by MSA? You minimize the DOGE effects on the DC MSA. I live here and this has had a real profound effect on the region. Neighbors loosing jobs and homes. School systems looking at changing enrollments, funding , all of Virginia looking for ways to shore up money needs for the south and west of the state since NOVA has been hot so hard.
Please dont just make stuff up to fill the content rules.
Thanks for the comment Rick and for keeping us honest. Bummed to hear that this disappointed but appreciate the feedback. We thought both the political shading of metropolitan areas was novel and meaningful, breaking us out of the blue counties and red hinterlands understanding of the political landscape, and then we thought the trends themselves were worth noting on two levels. First, the divergence across groups that was not present in 2023/2024 but then quite apparent come 2025 (not causal, just descriptive), and second, the variation within groups. The point we were trying to make with DC is that it clearly has been walloped by policy choices of the Trump administration, but that those more localized dynamics do not fully account for everything that's happening in very blue metros as a group. The result is a map of a lot more seeming randomness (itself a troubling development!): some places hit by tariffs hard, others insulated; some university systems struggling with funding cuts, others carrying on; some political battlegrounds still struggling with population decline and now a trade war, others still riding the tailwinds of population growth. The balance of that randomness is more pain in blue areas, for reasons that have more to do with local particularities than industry mix alone, relatively less pain in swingy areas, but slower job growth almost everywhere. Those additional reflections might not change your feeling about the piece but I'm grateful for the chance to air them -- the randomness that is a direct product of the new environment of unpredictability and cynicism is an important dynamic that we left unaddressed in the post itself.
I tend to like your articles. This one leaves me cold. In the past, employment and unemployment have been big players in voters sense of what is happening in their area. Now it is clearly inflation, corruption and terrible trade decisions. These are hard to analyze at the local level, I get this.
I am wondering why you choose to tackle this analysis at all. the differences are small, somewhat meaningless compared to inflation, policies and war, and tarrifs. As you point out MSA's are not perfect political boundaries. Perhaps looking for export/import effects of the tarrifs by MSA? You minimize the DOGE effects on the DC MSA. I live here and this has had a real profound effect on the region. Neighbors loosing jobs and homes. School systems looking at changing enrollments, funding , all of Virginia looking for ways to shore up money needs for the south and west of the state since NOVA has been hot so hard.
Please dont just make stuff up to fill the content rules.
Thanks for the comment Rick and for keeping us honest. Bummed to hear that this disappointed but appreciate the feedback. We thought both the political shading of metropolitan areas was novel and meaningful, breaking us out of the blue counties and red hinterlands understanding of the political landscape, and then we thought the trends themselves were worth noting on two levels. First, the divergence across groups that was not present in 2023/2024 but then quite apparent come 2025 (not causal, just descriptive), and second, the variation within groups. The point we were trying to make with DC is that it clearly has been walloped by policy choices of the Trump administration, but that those more localized dynamics do not fully account for everything that's happening in very blue metros as a group. The result is a map of a lot more seeming randomness (itself a troubling development!): some places hit by tariffs hard, others insulated; some university systems struggling with funding cuts, others carrying on; some political battlegrounds still struggling with population decline and now a trade war, others still riding the tailwinds of population growth. The balance of that randomness is more pain in blue areas, for reasons that have more to do with local particularities than industry mix alone, relatively less pain in swingy areas, but slower job growth almost everywhere. Those additional reflections might not change your feeling about the piece but I'm grateful for the chance to air them -- the randomness that is a direct product of the new environment of unpredictability and cynicism is an important dynamic that we left unaddressed in the post itself.